Apple iPhone
If you haven't heard of the Apple iPhone by now, then you're a bushman who lives in the Kalahari Desert, there are at least three "click" sounds in your name, and there is no possible way you can be reading this right now. The rest of you have been slammed by every possible media to be SURE you know of the latest chunk of techno geekery to come out of Apple - The iPhone, a gadget that plays music, plays video, has a touch screen web browser and - get this - places phone calls. Update patches may also include a can opener, cab fare, and a reasonable withdrawal of forces in the Middle East. Or not. Either way, you will pay through the nose for it. Like everything "cool" that runs on electrons, the iPhone is wicked expensive. And I do not mean the handset itself. (Though it is too - $499.) The pricing plans for using the thing are, to my way of thinking, astronomical:
Courtesy of Yahoo! Tech Blog AT&T is selling half the amount of minutes offered for this price by other cell companies. They also do not take into account the $36 set up fee, nor the required two-year contract. All for a gizmo that is just supposed to make phone calls - a function that not long ago could be taken care of in a booth for a quarter. Sure, the iPhone also plays music and videos... but guess what? If you don't activate it as a phone, NONE of the features will work. If you plan on buying this as a hip music/video player that you will someday use as a phone, you will find yourself the owner of an iPaperweight. And you will be iSad. And did I mention that the phone will run on EDGE, the slower, third generation cellular network? I did not, but I pretended not to know as a literary device to illicit awe. Not that I needed to - how awed will you be when you shell out all of that money, and you find yourself stuck with a below-average phone? I think it interesting to hear that even Verizon took a pass on the iPhone. The point I'm getting at is that these "neat" items are not only questionably useful, they are hideously over-priced. Are all of the features on this phone interesting and fun? Absolutely! The idea that I could switch from my music to an incoming phone call while jogging is a hoot. So is the utility of going on line while waiting at the airport. But ask yourself: Do you find yourself in that situation often? Apple is banking on enough people paying all of that money just for something that is, admittedly, exceedingly keen. In my opinion, however, all the money being asked for will be the bucket of ice cold water thrown in their collective faces. Fact is, cell phones themselves were inhibitivly expensive only a few years ago. Only CEOs - of major corporations - could afford to have them. Now high school students change up cell phones about once a year. Market demand increased the number of phones being built, and competition brought down the price of both service plans and handsets. My advice is to wait another five years for this kind of device. Make no mistake, the features and utility are definitely not empty promises, and this kind of phone is definitely the wave of the future. The problem is that this isn't the future - it's the present. And we have other things to spend our money on today.




6 comments so far
Weekend Reading 06.29.07: IABC & iPhones « Valley PR Blog says:
[...] Apple iPhone - Eric at Off Madison Ave says don’t buy an iPhone - or the hype (for starters, you can’t go running with it!) (Off Madison Ave 6/28/07) [...]
Aaron Post says:
Is it really that expensive?
Video Ipod cost $349 for the 80gb model.
My Cellphone cost about $120, then there was the two year agreement along with the extra charges for text messages, web access and more.
While some of the features may be excessive, its has just enough things like google maps and a screen that I can finaly see something on. Its not perfect but it will finally get the other phone manufactures to start thinking about design and usability.
In the end that is what you are really paying for, clean funcational design with a killer feature or two. I would think that would be something you or Off-Madison would endorse?
One more thing, like all things technical there is a hack for using the phone without connecting to AT&T - http://nanocr.eu/2007/07/03/iphone-without-att/
Just my 2 cents.
Eric says:
Personally, considering what you get with any Apple product, I would say it is too expensive for what you are getting. This has less to do with the iPhone then it does with Apple's own exorbitancy.
Ultimately I think the lines will be drawn the same way they are drawn for people who buy a Mac or a PC: You get what you pay for, but how much do you REALLY want to pay?
But don't think this is an Off Madison Ave opinion of the iPhone; it is worth noting that my boss, Roger Hurni, thought I was dead wrong.
And he uses a Mac. :)
Quebedox says:
Because someone had to:
http://amiel.typepad.com/photos/uncategorized/announcing_the_apple_iproduct_1.gif
Natala says:
Hi everyone. If we fall, we don't need self-recrimination or blame or anger - we need a reawakening of our intention and a willingness to recommit, to be whole-hearted once again.
I am from Sao and too poorly know English, give please true I wrote the following sentence: "Fleas are responsible for the production and transmission of several diseases of."
With respect :-(, Natala.
Molly says:
Hi everyone. Anything looked at closely becomes wonderful. Help me! Need information about: Walla walla dodge dealers. I found only this - san antonio Dodge dealers. Ford dealers ankeny dodge dealers ankeny jeep dealers ankeny ford dealers iowa dodge dealers iowa jeep dealers iowa ford I twurled news beta. Ford dealers ankeny dodge dealers ankeny jeep dealers ankeny ford dealers iowa dodge dealers iowa jeep dealers iowa ford I twurled news beta. ;-) Thanks in advance. Molly from Finland.